The Emergence of an Islamic Approach in Post-Westphalian International Relations

Document Type: Original Article

Author

M.A. student of Islamic Studies and Political Science at Imam Sadiq University

Abstract

Islam has a specific approach to the nature of international relations, which is different from two main international discourses, namely, realism and liberalism. In terms of ontological and epistemological foundations, schools in international relations differ from one another and as a result, their approach to international relations is different. This paper intends to compare the ontology foundations of the Islamic approach to international relations in comparison to both realism and liberalism approaches. However, two questions are discussed in this article: First, what are the ontological foundations of the international relations approach? Second, what is the difference between the Islamic theory of international relations and liberalism and realism approaches? In response to these questions, two hypotheses are stated:  First, the foundations of the ontology of international relations in Islam, in the dimension of anthropology, are neither pessimistic as realism, nor optimistic as idealism; but in Islamic perspective, human nature is a mixture of nature and instinct and  since a Muslim accepts the unseen affairs (qayb) and the absolute divine rule based on his nature, his understanding of politics is a sharia-based and in his view, the principle dominated over international relations is peace-centered. Second, the most important distinction between the Islamic approach to international relations and realism and liberalism is the ontological foundations of this theory. Regarding to these foundations, it has been able to provide an interpretation of the nature of international relations which is more consistent with the reality of the international system. The method of the research is analytical and the way of collecting is a documentary type.

Keywords


Amid Zanjani, Abbas Ali (2004) Political Philosophy: Laws and Rules of Conflict in the Field of Islamic Jihad and Islamic International Law, Tehran, Amir Kabir.

Berzouni, Mohammad Ali (2005) “Islam, Authenticity of War or Peace”, Journal of Law, No. 33.

Buzan, Barry (2008) From International to World Ssociety? English School Theory and the Social Structur of Globalization, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Danilovic, Resna & Joe Clar (2009) “The Kantian Liberal Peace” (revisited), American Journal of Political Science 51(2).

Dehghani Firoozabadi, Seyyed Jalal (2010) the Principles of Transtheoretical Islamic Theory of International Relations, International Journal of Foreign Relations, Second Year, No. 6, summer.

Dehghani Firoozabadi, Seyyed Jalal (2010) “Islam and theories of international relations, the metatheoretical approach”, Islam and international relations (subjective, thematic and analytical frameworks) by Hosein Pourahmadi, Imam Sadiq University Press.

Eftekhari, Asghar (2010) “International Peace and Security; Islamic Approach”, Islam and international relations (subjective, thematic and analytical frameworks) by Hosein Pourahmadi, Imam Sadiq University Press.

Fearon, J. and Wendt, A. (2002) “Rationalism and Constructivism: A Skeptical View”, in W. Carlsnaes, T. Risse and B.A. Simmons (eds), Handbook of International Relations, London: Sage.

Gilpin, R. (1986) “The Richness of the Tradition of Political Realism”, in R. Keohane (ed.), Neorealism and Its Critics, New York: Columbia University Press.

Hanson, Eric (2010) Religion and Politics in the Contemporary International System, Translated by Arsalan Ghorbani Sheikh Nin, Imam Sadiq University Press, First Edition.

Harrall, Andrew (2008) On Global Order, Oxford University Prees.

Johns, Anthony H. Hellahood, Nelli (2010) Islam and International Politics, Translated by Seyyed Reza Simber, Imam Sadeq University Press, First Edition

Khalilian, Khalil (1368) Islamic International Law, Third Edition, Tehran: Islamic Ma’areif Publishing.

Mirahmadi, Mansour (2010) Islamic Discourse and Global Discourse, Islam and international relations (subjective, thematic and analytical frameworks) by Hosein Pourahmadi, Imam Sadiq University Press.

Motahari, Morteza (2000) Collection of Works, Tehran, Sadra Publication Volume 2.

Mustafa Moghadam, Hamed (2003) “The scenes of peace and reconciliation, the glow in the work of the Prophet “, history of Islam, the representative institution of the Supreme Leader in the universities.

Powell, Robert (2009) “War as a Commitment Problem”, International Organization 60(1).

Sajjadi, Abdul Qayum (2002) “Diplomacy and Political Behavior in Islam”, Journal of Political Science, Fifth Year, No. 19, autumn.

Sayyid Qutb (1368) Islam and World Peace, translated by Zainuddin Ghorbani and Hadi Khosrow Shahi, Tehran, Islamic Culture Publishing.

Schmidt, B.C. (2002) “On the History and Historiography of International Relations”, in W. Carlsnaes, T. Risse and B.A. Simmons (eds), Handbook of International Relations. London: Sage.

Simbor and Ghorbani sheikh Neshin, Arsalan (2010) Islamism in the international system, Imam Sadiq University Press.

Smith, Karen (2009) “Constructing Africa (ns) in International Relations Theory”, Paper Presented to the Annual Meeting of ISA-Abreact Puc-Rio De Janiro, BRAZIL, Jully22.

Snidal Duncan & eds (2010) The Oxford Hand Book of International Relations, Oxford University Press.

Suganami, H. (2009) “Narrative Explanation and International Relation: Back to Basics”, Millennium: journal of international studies 37(2).

Wagner. R. Harrison (2008) “Theory of Iinternational Politics”, Chapter1 in War and the State: TheTheory of International Politics. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Prees.